Why were there no remains left in the “Killer Within” episode of The Walking Dead?Why does Andrea later...
Why do passenger jet manufacturers design their planes with stall prevention systems?
Instead of a Universal Basic Income program, why not implement a "Universal Basic Needs" program?
Could the Saturn V actually have launched astronauts around Venus?
ERC721: How to get the owned tokens of an address
Do the common programs (for example: "ls", "cat") in Linux and BSD come from the same source code?
If I am holding an item before I cast Blink, will it move with me through the Ethereal Plane?
Fastest way to pop N items from a large dict
Is there a symmetric-key algorithm which we can use for creating a signature?
Why one should not leave fingerprints on bulbs and plugs?
How to make healing in an exploration game interesting
Brexit - No Deal Rejection
Why Choose Less Effective Armour Types?
Can I use USB data pins as a power source?
How do you talk to someone whose loved one is dying?
Knife as defense against stray dogs
This word with a lot of past tenses
Is there a hypothetical scenario that would make Earth uninhabitable for humans, but not for (the majority of) other animals?
What did “the good wine” (τὸν καλὸν οἶνον) mean in John 2:10?
How do I hide Chekhov's Gun?
Relationship between sampajanna definitions in SN 47.2 and SN 47.35
Most cost effective thermostat setting: consistent temperature vs. lowest temperature possible
What are substitutions for coconut in curry?
Aluminum electrolytic or ceramic capacitors for linear regulator input and output?
Custom alignment for GeoMarkers
Why were there no remains left in the “Killer Within” episode of The Walking Dead?
Why does Andrea later look like Amy in The Walking Dead comics?In The Walking Dead (TV), how do zombies walk without blood circulating?Why didn't Michonne kill the Governor?What's the significance of the open to the pilot of The Walking Dead?Why are the survivors in The Walking Dead (TV show) so keen on killing each other?Is the zombie-to-human ratio ever mentioned in-universe in The Walking Dead?Why don't the people in Walking Dead just cover themselves in blood?Has anyone revealed why the word “zombie” is used in the comics, but not on the show(s)?Do the cast members of The Walking Dead read the comic books?Is the plot and delivery of The Walking Dead season 6 partly motivated by cost control?
In one of the episodes of The Walking Dead, "Killer Within"
Lori was eaten by a Zombie. Why wasn't there anything left of her body when Rick goes back to the room in "Say The Word"? Even her clothes were devoured?
the-walking-dead
add a comment |
In one of the episodes of The Walking Dead, "Killer Within"
Lori was eaten by a Zombie. Why wasn't there anything left of her body when Rick goes back to the room in "Say The Word"? Even her clothes were devoured?
the-walking-dead
2
Welcome to this site! I took the liberty of changing your title. Please keep in mind overly broad titles such as "Walking Dead series" are not very helpful, since they don't tell readers what the actual question is.
– Andres F.
Jan 21 '14 at 2:43
add a comment |
In one of the episodes of The Walking Dead, "Killer Within"
Lori was eaten by a Zombie. Why wasn't there anything left of her body when Rick goes back to the room in "Say The Word"? Even her clothes were devoured?
the-walking-dead
In one of the episodes of The Walking Dead, "Killer Within"
Lori was eaten by a Zombie. Why wasn't there anything left of her body when Rick goes back to the room in "Say The Word"? Even her clothes were devoured?
the-walking-dead
the-walking-dead
edited Jan 21 '14 at 16:26
phantom42
112k47496731
112k47496731
asked Jan 21 '14 at 1:00
user21860user21860
14112
14112
2
Welcome to this site! I took the liberty of changing your title. Please keep in mind overly broad titles such as "Walking Dead series" are not very helpful, since they don't tell readers what the actual question is.
– Andres F.
Jan 21 '14 at 2:43
add a comment |
2
Welcome to this site! I took the liberty of changing your title. Please keep in mind overly broad titles such as "Walking Dead series" are not very helpful, since they don't tell readers what the actual question is.
– Andres F.
Jan 21 '14 at 2:43
2
2
Welcome to this site! I took the liberty of changing your title. Please keep in mind overly broad titles such as "Walking Dead series" are not very helpful, since they don't tell readers what the actual question is.
– Andres F.
Jan 21 '14 at 2:43
Welcome to this site! I took the liberty of changing your title. Please keep in mind overly broad titles such as "Walking Dead series" are not very helpful, since they don't tell readers what the actual question is.
– Andres F.
Jan 21 '14 at 2:43
add a comment |
3 Answers
3
active
oldest
votes
What we know:
- Lori died during childbirth.
- Carl claims to have killed Walker-Lori, but it was done off-screen if it ever happened.
- Rick went to recover the body but only found a walker that looked like it had very recently fed.
So, what happened to the body? Has it really been totally consumed, or is Lori a walker now?
No official answer has ever been given, but there was a deleted scene fueling the Walker-Lori theory.
The final version showed Rick talking to what appears to be a vision of Lori. The full version pulls back to show Lori as a walker.
But Walker-Lori appears to be wearing the white dress Live-Lori wears in the vision (it's cropped out of frame, but the straps are slightly visible), and neither Lori can be seen in the wide shot. Lori was not wearing the dress when she died and the white dress is likely just symbolic.
So is Lori really a walker out there somewhere? The other possibility is that she's not a walker at all. She's survived the c-section and is living/hiding somewhere. This would explain the lack of remains or clothes.
Both the Walker-Lori and Survivor-Lori theories are extremely unlikely, but without a body or remains of any sort, we have no conclusive evidence of Lori's fate.
Beyond being a poorly cropped version of the video, the "so-called" zombie-version of Lori does not seek to eat Rick. If this were reality, and not one of his hallucinations, she would have started eating him at the kiss if not before. It has been established that the zombie's humanity and / or care for loved-ones is gone. I find this to be non-evidence of Lori as a walker/zombie. It is evidence of Rick losing his grip on reality.
– Meat Trademark
Jan 21 '14 at 2:55
1
I absolutely agree, but there are apparently some people who cling to any theory.
– phantom42
Jan 21 '14 at 3:05
I feel my answer is more accurate, but your answer is thoughtful and comprehensive so I won't vote it down.
– Meat Trademark
Jan 21 '14 at 4:06
add a comment |
In the episode "Killer Within," Lori died during childbirth and Carl "killed" her.
I have not seen compelling evidence that Carl did not kill Lori after the birth. The look on his face as he is walking away after the gunshot tells the story. It seems that all the subsequent scenes are due to the madness that initiates Rick's further hallucinations via the phone-calls and such.
After watching his mother die while giving birth via C-section, a distraught Carl shoots her per her request to prevent reanimation.
Carl did what needed to be done and that fits with his character arc; after this he becomes more resolved. He was not fully raised in the pre-zombie world and wants to be responsible and respected for being wise beyond his age in this new reality. Carl is cold and his moral code is being formulated in a world not conducive to being a child or having a childhood. He is stepping up and the toll that takes on him shows.
As for Lori: completely dead, I see no ambiguity here.
The OP's question makes no sense. There is never a shot of the room Lori died in showing no corpse or clothing in the episode "Killer Within." Even the next episode does not provide compelling evidence of this. It doesn't make much sense.
EDIT: Since the OP's question has changed, I feel I should update this. The fact her clothes are not there is non-evidence. It's possible (but unlikely) that Carl missed her brain, or didn't shoot her at all. I think it's more likely the clothes were in another part of the cell or she was dragged away (less likely as it would have left a trail). The most probable ideas here are that the clothes are there, just not shown or the bloated zombie did eat them (seems unlikely as clothes are not flesh). This leaves the "clothes are there, just not shown" as most likely. When the producer says "he sees the stain of his wife and really nothing else," he seems to be talking about her as person. Why would he mention off-screen clothing when he didn't mention the knife right next to the stain? It's wasn't hyperbole, just an economy of words to drive home the devastation done to Rick. "He sees the stain, a bunk, a knife, some clothes, but little else," is not as conducive to the point he's making.
I'm unsure of the name of the episode, but yes, that did happen in the AMC version. It was a teenager that came to the prison with The Governor. Hershell (sp) was with Carl and told him not to shoot him because the kid was going to put down his rifle (or shotgun, I have forgotten which). Carl ends up blasting him in the head. If I recall correctly, this happened after Lori's death, however.
– Dave H
Jan 21 '14 at 14:54
I don't mean that incident, I mean the one where Carl sneaked out at night and killed someone he thought was a threat to the safety of the group. A kid who I think killed another kid. A delinquent type who already compromised the integrity of the group. And I seem to remember Hershel (or possibly someone else in the group) being privy to this info, but keeping it secret.
– Meat Trademark
Jan 21 '14 at 15:02
This doesn't answer the question. The question was "why wasn't there anything left?" And had nothing to do with whether or not Carl did or didn't... let alone why... or his thoughts about it... or his development as a character ;-) Lots of information, but very little of it is directed at the question asked.
– Matt
Jan 21 '14 at 15:24
1
OK, then you're talking about Ben. Ben was a little psychopath and Carl killed him in the comics. (It's possible that Ben is a template for the new girls on the show.)
– phantom42
Jan 21 '14 at 16:15
1
Watch the video I've added to the question. The Exec Producer comments on the scene saying Rick finds nothing but a stain and a zombie with bones in his throat, but no body of Lori.
– phantom42
Jan 21 '14 at 16:28
|
show 7 more comments
Wait - I’m on season 4 ep 14 — Maggie’s about to write a letter on a blank sign board and then a zombie comes over .. she stabs the zombie and then opens its belly - could that have been Lori ?
New contributor
add a comment |
Your Answer
StackExchange.ready(function() {
var channelOptions = {
tags: "".split(" "),
id: "186"
};
initTagRenderer("".split(" "), "".split(" "), channelOptions);
StackExchange.using("externalEditor", function() {
// Have to fire editor after snippets, if snippets enabled
if (StackExchange.settings.snippets.snippetsEnabled) {
StackExchange.using("snippets", function() {
createEditor();
});
}
else {
createEditor();
}
});
function createEditor() {
StackExchange.prepareEditor({
heartbeatType: 'answer',
autoActivateHeartbeat: false,
convertImagesToLinks: false,
noModals: true,
showLowRepImageUploadWarning: true,
reputationToPostImages: null,
bindNavPrevention: true,
postfix: "",
imageUploader: {
brandingHtml: "Powered by u003ca class="icon-imgur-white" href="https://imgur.com/"u003eu003c/au003e",
contentPolicyHtml: "User contributions licensed under u003ca href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/"u003ecc by-sa 3.0 with attribution requiredu003c/au003e u003ca href="https://stackoverflow.com/legal/content-policy"u003e(content policy)u003c/au003e",
allowUrls: true
},
noCode: true, onDemand: true,
discardSelector: ".discard-answer"
,immediatelyShowMarkdownHelp:true
});
}
});
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
StackExchange.ready(
function () {
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fscifi.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f48546%2fwhy-were-there-no-remains-left-in-the-killer-within-episode-of-the-walking-dea%23new-answer', 'question_page');
}
);
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
3 Answers
3
active
oldest
votes
3 Answers
3
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
What we know:
- Lori died during childbirth.
- Carl claims to have killed Walker-Lori, but it was done off-screen if it ever happened.
- Rick went to recover the body but only found a walker that looked like it had very recently fed.
So, what happened to the body? Has it really been totally consumed, or is Lori a walker now?
No official answer has ever been given, but there was a deleted scene fueling the Walker-Lori theory.
The final version showed Rick talking to what appears to be a vision of Lori. The full version pulls back to show Lori as a walker.
But Walker-Lori appears to be wearing the white dress Live-Lori wears in the vision (it's cropped out of frame, but the straps are slightly visible), and neither Lori can be seen in the wide shot. Lori was not wearing the dress when she died and the white dress is likely just symbolic.
So is Lori really a walker out there somewhere? The other possibility is that she's not a walker at all. She's survived the c-section and is living/hiding somewhere. This would explain the lack of remains or clothes.
Both the Walker-Lori and Survivor-Lori theories are extremely unlikely, but without a body or remains of any sort, we have no conclusive evidence of Lori's fate.
Beyond being a poorly cropped version of the video, the "so-called" zombie-version of Lori does not seek to eat Rick. If this were reality, and not one of his hallucinations, she would have started eating him at the kiss if not before. It has been established that the zombie's humanity and / or care for loved-ones is gone. I find this to be non-evidence of Lori as a walker/zombie. It is evidence of Rick losing his grip on reality.
– Meat Trademark
Jan 21 '14 at 2:55
1
I absolutely agree, but there are apparently some people who cling to any theory.
– phantom42
Jan 21 '14 at 3:05
I feel my answer is more accurate, but your answer is thoughtful and comprehensive so I won't vote it down.
– Meat Trademark
Jan 21 '14 at 4:06
add a comment |
What we know:
- Lori died during childbirth.
- Carl claims to have killed Walker-Lori, but it was done off-screen if it ever happened.
- Rick went to recover the body but only found a walker that looked like it had very recently fed.
So, what happened to the body? Has it really been totally consumed, or is Lori a walker now?
No official answer has ever been given, but there was a deleted scene fueling the Walker-Lori theory.
The final version showed Rick talking to what appears to be a vision of Lori. The full version pulls back to show Lori as a walker.
But Walker-Lori appears to be wearing the white dress Live-Lori wears in the vision (it's cropped out of frame, but the straps are slightly visible), and neither Lori can be seen in the wide shot. Lori was not wearing the dress when she died and the white dress is likely just symbolic.
So is Lori really a walker out there somewhere? The other possibility is that she's not a walker at all. She's survived the c-section and is living/hiding somewhere. This would explain the lack of remains or clothes.
Both the Walker-Lori and Survivor-Lori theories are extremely unlikely, but without a body or remains of any sort, we have no conclusive evidence of Lori's fate.
Beyond being a poorly cropped version of the video, the "so-called" zombie-version of Lori does not seek to eat Rick. If this were reality, and not one of his hallucinations, she would have started eating him at the kiss if not before. It has been established that the zombie's humanity and / or care for loved-ones is gone. I find this to be non-evidence of Lori as a walker/zombie. It is evidence of Rick losing his grip on reality.
– Meat Trademark
Jan 21 '14 at 2:55
1
I absolutely agree, but there are apparently some people who cling to any theory.
– phantom42
Jan 21 '14 at 3:05
I feel my answer is more accurate, but your answer is thoughtful and comprehensive so I won't vote it down.
– Meat Trademark
Jan 21 '14 at 4:06
add a comment |
What we know:
- Lori died during childbirth.
- Carl claims to have killed Walker-Lori, but it was done off-screen if it ever happened.
- Rick went to recover the body but only found a walker that looked like it had very recently fed.
So, what happened to the body? Has it really been totally consumed, or is Lori a walker now?
No official answer has ever been given, but there was a deleted scene fueling the Walker-Lori theory.
The final version showed Rick talking to what appears to be a vision of Lori. The full version pulls back to show Lori as a walker.
But Walker-Lori appears to be wearing the white dress Live-Lori wears in the vision (it's cropped out of frame, but the straps are slightly visible), and neither Lori can be seen in the wide shot. Lori was not wearing the dress when she died and the white dress is likely just symbolic.
So is Lori really a walker out there somewhere? The other possibility is that she's not a walker at all. She's survived the c-section and is living/hiding somewhere. This would explain the lack of remains or clothes.
Both the Walker-Lori and Survivor-Lori theories are extremely unlikely, but without a body or remains of any sort, we have no conclusive evidence of Lori's fate.
What we know:
- Lori died during childbirth.
- Carl claims to have killed Walker-Lori, but it was done off-screen if it ever happened.
- Rick went to recover the body but only found a walker that looked like it had very recently fed.
So, what happened to the body? Has it really been totally consumed, or is Lori a walker now?
No official answer has ever been given, but there was a deleted scene fueling the Walker-Lori theory.
The final version showed Rick talking to what appears to be a vision of Lori. The full version pulls back to show Lori as a walker.
But Walker-Lori appears to be wearing the white dress Live-Lori wears in the vision (it's cropped out of frame, but the straps are slightly visible), and neither Lori can be seen in the wide shot. Lori was not wearing the dress when she died and the white dress is likely just symbolic.
So is Lori really a walker out there somewhere? The other possibility is that she's not a walker at all. She's survived the c-section and is living/hiding somewhere. This would explain the lack of remains or clothes.
Both the Walker-Lori and Survivor-Lori theories are extremely unlikely, but without a body or remains of any sort, we have no conclusive evidence of Lori's fate.
edited Jan 21 '14 at 15:22
answered Jan 21 '14 at 2:45
phantom42phantom42
112k47496731
112k47496731
Beyond being a poorly cropped version of the video, the "so-called" zombie-version of Lori does not seek to eat Rick. If this were reality, and not one of his hallucinations, she would have started eating him at the kiss if not before. It has been established that the zombie's humanity and / or care for loved-ones is gone. I find this to be non-evidence of Lori as a walker/zombie. It is evidence of Rick losing his grip on reality.
– Meat Trademark
Jan 21 '14 at 2:55
1
I absolutely agree, but there are apparently some people who cling to any theory.
– phantom42
Jan 21 '14 at 3:05
I feel my answer is more accurate, but your answer is thoughtful and comprehensive so I won't vote it down.
– Meat Trademark
Jan 21 '14 at 4:06
add a comment |
Beyond being a poorly cropped version of the video, the "so-called" zombie-version of Lori does not seek to eat Rick. If this were reality, and not one of his hallucinations, she would have started eating him at the kiss if not before. It has been established that the zombie's humanity and / or care for loved-ones is gone. I find this to be non-evidence of Lori as a walker/zombie. It is evidence of Rick losing his grip on reality.
– Meat Trademark
Jan 21 '14 at 2:55
1
I absolutely agree, but there are apparently some people who cling to any theory.
– phantom42
Jan 21 '14 at 3:05
I feel my answer is more accurate, but your answer is thoughtful and comprehensive so I won't vote it down.
– Meat Trademark
Jan 21 '14 at 4:06
Beyond being a poorly cropped version of the video, the "so-called" zombie-version of Lori does not seek to eat Rick. If this were reality, and not one of his hallucinations, she would have started eating him at the kiss if not before. It has been established that the zombie's humanity and / or care for loved-ones is gone. I find this to be non-evidence of Lori as a walker/zombie. It is evidence of Rick losing his grip on reality.
– Meat Trademark
Jan 21 '14 at 2:55
Beyond being a poorly cropped version of the video, the "so-called" zombie-version of Lori does not seek to eat Rick. If this were reality, and not one of his hallucinations, she would have started eating him at the kiss if not before. It has been established that the zombie's humanity and / or care for loved-ones is gone. I find this to be non-evidence of Lori as a walker/zombie. It is evidence of Rick losing his grip on reality.
– Meat Trademark
Jan 21 '14 at 2:55
1
1
I absolutely agree, but there are apparently some people who cling to any theory.
– phantom42
Jan 21 '14 at 3:05
I absolutely agree, but there are apparently some people who cling to any theory.
– phantom42
Jan 21 '14 at 3:05
I feel my answer is more accurate, but your answer is thoughtful and comprehensive so I won't vote it down.
– Meat Trademark
Jan 21 '14 at 4:06
I feel my answer is more accurate, but your answer is thoughtful and comprehensive so I won't vote it down.
– Meat Trademark
Jan 21 '14 at 4:06
add a comment |
In the episode "Killer Within," Lori died during childbirth and Carl "killed" her.
I have not seen compelling evidence that Carl did not kill Lori after the birth. The look on his face as he is walking away after the gunshot tells the story. It seems that all the subsequent scenes are due to the madness that initiates Rick's further hallucinations via the phone-calls and such.
After watching his mother die while giving birth via C-section, a distraught Carl shoots her per her request to prevent reanimation.
Carl did what needed to be done and that fits with his character arc; after this he becomes more resolved. He was not fully raised in the pre-zombie world and wants to be responsible and respected for being wise beyond his age in this new reality. Carl is cold and his moral code is being formulated in a world not conducive to being a child or having a childhood. He is stepping up and the toll that takes on him shows.
As for Lori: completely dead, I see no ambiguity here.
The OP's question makes no sense. There is never a shot of the room Lori died in showing no corpse or clothing in the episode "Killer Within." Even the next episode does not provide compelling evidence of this. It doesn't make much sense.
EDIT: Since the OP's question has changed, I feel I should update this. The fact her clothes are not there is non-evidence. It's possible (but unlikely) that Carl missed her brain, or didn't shoot her at all. I think it's more likely the clothes were in another part of the cell or she was dragged away (less likely as it would have left a trail). The most probable ideas here are that the clothes are there, just not shown or the bloated zombie did eat them (seems unlikely as clothes are not flesh). This leaves the "clothes are there, just not shown" as most likely. When the producer says "he sees the stain of his wife and really nothing else," he seems to be talking about her as person. Why would he mention off-screen clothing when he didn't mention the knife right next to the stain? It's wasn't hyperbole, just an economy of words to drive home the devastation done to Rick. "He sees the stain, a bunk, a knife, some clothes, but little else," is not as conducive to the point he's making.
I'm unsure of the name of the episode, but yes, that did happen in the AMC version. It was a teenager that came to the prison with The Governor. Hershell (sp) was with Carl and told him not to shoot him because the kid was going to put down his rifle (or shotgun, I have forgotten which). Carl ends up blasting him in the head. If I recall correctly, this happened after Lori's death, however.
– Dave H
Jan 21 '14 at 14:54
I don't mean that incident, I mean the one where Carl sneaked out at night and killed someone he thought was a threat to the safety of the group. A kid who I think killed another kid. A delinquent type who already compromised the integrity of the group. And I seem to remember Hershel (or possibly someone else in the group) being privy to this info, but keeping it secret.
– Meat Trademark
Jan 21 '14 at 15:02
This doesn't answer the question. The question was "why wasn't there anything left?" And had nothing to do with whether or not Carl did or didn't... let alone why... or his thoughts about it... or his development as a character ;-) Lots of information, but very little of it is directed at the question asked.
– Matt
Jan 21 '14 at 15:24
1
OK, then you're talking about Ben. Ben was a little psychopath and Carl killed him in the comics. (It's possible that Ben is a template for the new girls on the show.)
– phantom42
Jan 21 '14 at 16:15
1
Watch the video I've added to the question. The Exec Producer comments on the scene saying Rick finds nothing but a stain and a zombie with bones in his throat, but no body of Lori.
– phantom42
Jan 21 '14 at 16:28
|
show 7 more comments
In the episode "Killer Within," Lori died during childbirth and Carl "killed" her.
I have not seen compelling evidence that Carl did not kill Lori after the birth. The look on his face as he is walking away after the gunshot tells the story. It seems that all the subsequent scenes are due to the madness that initiates Rick's further hallucinations via the phone-calls and such.
After watching his mother die while giving birth via C-section, a distraught Carl shoots her per her request to prevent reanimation.
Carl did what needed to be done and that fits with his character arc; after this he becomes more resolved. He was not fully raised in the pre-zombie world and wants to be responsible and respected for being wise beyond his age in this new reality. Carl is cold and his moral code is being formulated in a world not conducive to being a child or having a childhood. He is stepping up and the toll that takes on him shows.
As for Lori: completely dead, I see no ambiguity here.
The OP's question makes no sense. There is never a shot of the room Lori died in showing no corpse or clothing in the episode "Killer Within." Even the next episode does not provide compelling evidence of this. It doesn't make much sense.
EDIT: Since the OP's question has changed, I feel I should update this. The fact her clothes are not there is non-evidence. It's possible (but unlikely) that Carl missed her brain, or didn't shoot her at all. I think it's more likely the clothes were in another part of the cell or she was dragged away (less likely as it would have left a trail). The most probable ideas here are that the clothes are there, just not shown or the bloated zombie did eat them (seems unlikely as clothes are not flesh). This leaves the "clothes are there, just not shown" as most likely. When the producer says "he sees the stain of his wife and really nothing else," he seems to be talking about her as person. Why would he mention off-screen clothing when he didn't mention the knife right next to the stain? It's wasn't hyperbole, just an economy of words to drive home the devastation done to Rick. "He sees the stain, a bunk, a knife, some clothes, but little else," is not as conducive to the point he's making.
I'm unsure of the name of the episode, but yes, that did happen in the AMC version. It was a teenager that came to the prison with The Governor. Hershell (sp) was with Carl and told him not to shoot him because the kid was going to put down his rifle (or shotgun, I have forgotten which). Carl ends up blasting him in the head. If I recall correctly, this happened after Lori's death, however.
– Dave H
Jan 21 '14 at 14:54
I don't mean that incident, I mean the one where Carl sneaked out at night and killed someone he thought was a threat to the safety of the group. A kid who I think killed another kid. A delinquent type who already compromised the integrity of the group. And I seem to remember Hershel (or possibly someone else in the group) being privy to this info, but keeping it secret.
– Meat Trademark
Jan 21 '14 at 15:02
This doesn't answer the question. The question was "why wasn't there anything left?" And had nothing to do with whether or not Carl did or didn't... let alone why... or his thoughts about it... or his development as a character ;-) Lots of information, but very little of it is directed at the question asked.
– Matt
Jan 21 '14 at 15:24
1
OK, then you're talking about Ben. Ben was a little psychopath and Carl killed him in the comics. (It's possible that Ben is a template for the new girls on the show.)
– phantom42
Jan 21 '14 at 16:15
1
Watch the video I've added to the question. The Exec Producer comments on the scene saying Rick finds nothing but a stain and a zombie with bones in his throat, but no body of Lori.
– phantom42
Jan 21 '14 at 16:28
|
show 7 more comments
In the episode "Killer Within," Lori died during childbirth and Carl "killed" her.
I have not seen compelling evidence that Carl did not kill Lori after the birth. The look on his face as he is walking away after the gunshot tells the story. It seems that all the subsequent scenes are due to the madness that initiates Rick's further hallucinations via the phone-calls and such.
After watching his mother die while giving birth via C-section, a distraught Carl shoots her per her request to prevent reanimation.
Carl did what needed to be done and that fits with his character arc; after this he becomes more resolved. He was not fully raised in the pre-zombie world and wants to be responsible and respected for being wise beyond his age in this new reality. Carl is cold and his moral code is being formulated in a world not conducive to being a child or having a childhood. He is stepping up and the toll that takes on him shows.
As for Lori: completely dead, I see no ambiguity here.
The OP's question makes no sense. There is never a shot of the room Lori died in showing no corpse or clothing in the episode "Killer Within." Even the next episode does not provide compelling evidence of this. It doesn't make much sense.
EDIT: Since the OP's question has changed, I feel I should update this. The fact her clothes are not there is non-evidence. It's possible (but unlikely) that Carl missed her brain, or didn't shoot her at all. I think it's more likely the clothes were in another part of the cell or she was dragged away (less likely as it would have left a trail). The most probable ideas here are that the clothes are there, just not shown or the bloated zombie did eat them (seems unlikely as clothes are not flesh). This leaves the "clothes are there, just not shown" as most likely. When the producer says "he sees the stain of his wife and really nothing else," he seems to be talking about her as person. Why would he mention off-screen clothing when he didn't mention the knife right next to the stain? It's wasn't hyperbole, just an economy of words to drive home the devastation done to Rick. "He sees the stain, a bunk, a knife, some clothes, but little else," is not as conducive to the point he's making.
In the episode "Killer Within," Lori died during childbirth and Carl "killed" her.
I have not seen compelling evidence that Carl did not kill Lori after the birth. The look on his face as he is walking away after the gunshot tells the story. It seems that all the subsequent scenes are due to the madness that initiates Rick's further hallucinations via the phone-calls and such.
After watching his mother die while giving birth via C-section, a distraught Carl shoots her per her request to prevent reanimation.
Carl did what needed to be done and that fits with his character arc; after this he becomes more resolved. He was not fully raised in the pre-zombie world and wants to be responsible and respected for being wise beyond his age in this new reality. Carl is cold and his moral code is being formulated in a world not conducive to being a child or having a childhood. He is stepping up and the toll that takes on him shows.
As for Lori: completely dead, I see no ambiguity here.
The OP's question makes no sense. There is never a shot of the room Lori died in showing no corpse or clothing in the episode "Killer Within." Even the next episode does not provide compelling evidence of this. It doesn't make much sense.
EDIT: Since the OP's question has changed, I feel I should update this. The fact her clothes are not there is non-evidence. It's possible (but unlikely) that Carl missed her brain, or didn't shoot her at all. I think it's more likely the clothes were in another part of the cell or she was dragged away (less likely as it would have left a trail). The most probable ideas here are that the clothes are there, just not shown or the bloated zombie did eat them (seems unlikely as clothes are not flesh). This leaves the "clothes are there, just not shown" as most likely. When the producer says "he sees the stain of his wife and really nothing else," he seems to be talking about her as person. Why would he mention off-screen clothing when he didn't mention the knife right next to the stain? It's wasn't hyperbole, just an economy of words to drive home the devastation done to Rick. "He sees the stain, a bunk, a knife, some clothes, but little else," is not as conducive to the point he's making.
edited Jan 22 '14 at 12:01
answered Jan 21 '14 at 2:20
Meat TrademarkMeat Trademark
6,48443676
6,48443676
I'm unsure of the name of the episode, but yes, that did happen in the AMC version. It was a teenager that came to the prison with The Governor. Hershell (sp) was with Carl and told him not to shoot him because the kid was going to put down his rifle (or shotgun, I have forgotten which). Carl ends up blasting him in the head. If I recall correctly, this happened after Lori's death, however.
– Dave H
Jan 21 '14 at 14:54
I don't mean that incident, I mean the one where Carl sneaked out at night and killed someone he thought was a threat to the safety of the group. A kid who I think killed another kid. A delinquent type who already compromised the integrity of the group. And I seem to remember Hershel (or possibly someone else in the group) being privy to this info, but keeping it secret.
– Meat Trademark
Jan 21 '14 at 15:02
This doesn't answer the question. The question was "why wasn't there anything left?" And had nothing to do with whether or not Carl did or didn't... let alone why... or his thoughts about it... or his development as a character ;-) Lots of information, but very little of it is directed at the question asked.
– Matt
Jan 21 '14 at 15:24
1
OK, then you're talking about Ben. Ben was a little psychopath and Carl killed him in the comics. (It's possible that Ben is a template for the new girls on the show.)
– phantom42
Jan 21 '14 at 16:15
1
Watch the video I've added to the question. The Exec Producer comments on the scene saying Rick finds nothing but a stain and a zombie with bones in his throat, but no body of Lori.
– phantom42
Jan 21 '14 at 16:28
|
show 7 more comments
I'm unsure of the name of the episode, but yes, that did happen in the AMC version. It was a teenager that came to the prison with The Governor. Hershell (sp) was with Carl and told him not to shoot him because the kid was going to put down his rifle (or shotgun, I have forgotten which). Carl ends up blasting him in the head. If I recall correctly, this happened after Lori's death, however.
– Dave H
Jan 21 '14 at 14:54
I don't mean that incident, I mean the one where Carl sneaked out at night and killed someone he thought was a threat to the safety of the group. A kid who I think killed another kid. A delinquent type who already compromised the integrity of the group. And I seem to remember Hershel (or possibly someone else in the group) being privy to this info, but keeping it secret.
– Meat Trademark
Jan 21 '14 at 15:02
This doesn't answer the question. The question was "why wasn't there anything left?" And had nothing to do with whether or not Carl did or didn't... let alone why... or his thoughts about it... or his development as a character ;-) Lots of information, but very little of it is directed at the question asked.
– Matt
Jan 21 '14 at 15:24
1
OK, then you're talking about Ben. Ben was a little psychopath and Carl killed him in the comics. (It's possible that Ben is a template for the new girls on the show.)
– phantom42
Jan 21 '14 at 16:15
1
Watch the video I've added to the question. The Exec Producer comments on the scene saying Rick finds nothing but a stain and a zombie with bones in his throat, but no body of Lori.
– phantom42
Jan 21 '14 at 16:28
I'm unsure of the name of the episode, but yes, that did happen in the AMC version. It was a teenager that came to the prison with The Governor. Hershell (sp) was with Carl and told him not to shoot him because the kid was going to put down his rifle (or shotgun, I have forgotten which). Carl ends up blasting him in the head. If I recall correctly, this happened after Lori's death, however.
– Dave H
Jan 21 '14 at 14:54
I'm unsure of the name of the episode, but yes, that did happen in the AMC version. It was a teenager that came to the prison with The Governor. Hershell (sp) was with Carl and told him not to shoot him because the kid was going to put down his rifle (or shotgun, I have forgotten which). Carl ends up blasting him in the head. If I recall correctly, this happened after Lori's death, however.
– Dave H
Jan 21 '14 at 14:54
I don't mean that incident, I mean the one where Carl sneaked out at night and killed someone he thought was a threat to the safety of the group. A kid who I think killed another kid. A delinquent type who already compromised the integrity of the group. And I seem to remember Hershel (or possibly someone else in the group) being privy to this info, but keeping it secret.
– Meat Trademark
Jan 21 '14 at 15:02
I don't mean that incident, I mean the one where Carl sneaked out at night and killed someone he thought was a threat to the safety of the group. A kid who I think killed another kid. A delinquent type who already compromised the integrity of the group. And I seem to remember Hershel (or possibly someone else in the group) being privy to this info, but keeping it secret.
– Meat Trademark
Jan 21 '14 at 15:02
This doesn't answer the question. The question was "why wasn't there anything left?" And had nothing to do with whether or not Carl did or didn't... let alone why... or his thoughts about it... or his development as a character ;-) Lots of information, but very little of it is directed at the question asked.
– Matt
Jan 21 '14 at 15:24
This doesn't answer the question. The question was "why wasn't there anything left?" And had nothing to do with whether or not Carl did or didn't... let alone why... or his thoughts about it... or his development as a character ;-) Lots of information, but very little of it is directed at the question asked.
– Matt
Jan 21 '14 at 15:24
1
1
OK, then you're talking about Ben. Ben was a little psychopath and Carl killed him in the comics. (It's possible that Ben is a template for the new girls on the show.)
– phantom42
Jan 21 '14 at 16:15
OK, then you're talking about Ben. Ben was a little psychopath and Carl killed him in the comics. (It's possible that Ben is a template for the new girls on the show.)
– phantom42
Jan 21 '14 at 16:15
1
1
Watch the video I've added to the question. The Exec Producer comments on the scene saying Rick finds nothing but a stain and a zombie with bones in his throat, but no body of Lori.
– phantom42
Jan 21 '14 at 16:28
Watch the video I've added to the question. The Exec Producer comments on the scene saying Rick finds nothing but a stain and a zombie with bones in his throat, but no body of Lori.
– phantom42
Jan 21 '14 at 16:28
|
show 7 more comments
Wait - I’m on season 4 ep 14 — Maggie’s about to write a letter on a blank sign board and then a zombie comes over .. she stabs the zombie and then opens its belly - could that have been Lori ?
New contributor
add a comment |
Wait - I’m on season 4 ep 14 — Maggie’s about to write a letter on a blank sign board and then a zombie comes over .. she stabs the zombie and then opens its belly - could that have been Lori ?
New contributor
add a comment |
Wait - I’m on season 4 ep 14 — Maggie’s about to write a letter on a blank sign board and then a zombie comes over .. she stabs the zombie and then opens its belly - could that have been Lori ?
New contributor
Wait - I’m on season 4 ep 14 — Maggie’s about to write a letter on a blank sign board and then a zombie comes over .. she stabs the zombie and then opens its belly - could that have been Lori ?
New contributor
New contributor
answered 2 mins ago
Late2TWDLate2TWD
1
1
New contributor
New contributor
add a comment |
add a comment |
Thanks for contributing an answer to Science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange!
- Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!
But avoid …
- Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.
- Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.
To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
StackExchange.ready(
function () {
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fscifi.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f48546%2fwhy-were-there-no-remains-left-in-the-killer-within-episode-of-the-walking-dea%23new-answer', 'question_page');
}
);
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
2
Welcome to this site! I took the liberty of changing your title. Please keep in mind overly broad titles such as "Walking Dead series" are not very helpful, since they don't tell readers what the actual question is.
– Andres F.
Jan 21 '14 at 2:43