Story entitled “Something to Say”60s short story involving two humans, a Russian lady and an American...

Prime joint compound before latex paint?

Could Giant Ground Sloths have been a good pack animal for the ancient Mayans?

"My colleague's body is amazing"

New order #4: World

Is "plugging out" electronic devices an American expression?

What to wear for invited talk in Canada

Calculate Levenshtein distance between two strings in Python

Can a planet have a different gravitational pull depending on its location in orbit around its sun?

Copycat chess is back

What do you call something that goes against the spirit of the law, but is legal when interpreting the law to the letter?

How is it possible for user's password to be changed after storage was encrypted? (on OS X, Android)

Where else does the Shulchan Aruch quote an authority by name?

Domain expired, GoDaddy holds it and is asking more money

Why is my log file so massive? 22gb. I am running log backups

Finding files for which a command fails

"listening to me about as much as you're listening to this pole here"

A poker game description that does not feel gimmicky

What does "enim et" mean?

Typesetting a double Over Dot on top of a symbol

Was there ever an axiom rendered a theorem?

What happens when a metallic dragon and a chromatic dragon mate?

How to make payment on the internet without leaving a money trail?

How can I fix this gap between bookcases I made?

Is there a name of the flying bionic bird?



Story entitled “Something to Say”


60s short story involving two humans, a Russian lady and an American pacifistLooking for a short story named something like “Creatron”Short Story where something is looking at a manWhich film had “See something, say something” billboard with Muslim woman's face?Short story called “Idiot planet” or something similarStory about a stranded astronaut that needed 40-something identical parts to fix his engineSomething something: and the Scourge of (Rykard?)Horror Story Called “To Be A Man” or something similarLooking for a story where the protagonist used a weapon called spetsod or maybe something elseSomething, something “reality cowboys”?Our hero hems and haws and finally decides to summon the fleet to help his new alien buddies






.everyoneloves__top-leaderboard:empty,.everyoneloves__mid-leaderboard:empty,.everyoneloves__bot-mid-leaderboard:empty{ margin-bottom:0;
}







7















Russians and Americans are competing to make an alliance with an alien race that lives on a planet with a very thick atmosphere. Most of the plant life on the planet lives hanging in the air from gas bags. Because it is so easy to fly, the natives have developed very primitive aircraft. The Russians have sophisticated linguists who are trying to establish communication. The hero, an American, knows nothing about linguistics, but does know a thing or two about flying. He teaches the natives about the concept of a rudder, and they are so thankful they form an alliance with the Americans. The hero explains that having something to say is more important than how you say it.



I thought it was by Eric Frank Russell, but can't find it in his work. It was probably written in the 1950's or early 1960's.










share|improve this question































    7















    Russians and Americans are competing to make an alliance with an alien race that lives on a planet with a very thick atmosphere. Most of the plant life on the planet lives hanging in the air from gas bags. Because it is so easy to fly, the natives have developed very primitive aircraft. The Russians have sophisticated linguists who are trying to establish communication. The hero, an American, knows nothing about linguistics, but does know a thing or two about flying. He teaches the natives about the concept of a rudder, and they are so thankful they form an alliance with the Americans. The hero explains that having something to say is more important than how you say it.



    I thought it was by Eric Frank Russell, but can't find it in his work. It was probably written in the 1950's or early 1960's.










    share|improve this question



























      7












      7








      7


      1






      Russians and Americans are competing to make an alliance with an alien race that lives on a planet with a very thick atmosphere. Most of the plant life on the planet lives hanging in the air from gas bags. Because it is so easy to fly, the natives have developed very primitive aircraft. The Russians have sophisticated linguists who are trying to establish communication. The hero, an American, knows nothing about linguistics, but does know a thing or two about flying. He teaches the natives about the concept of a rudder, and they are so thankful they form an alliance with the Americans. The hero explains that having something to say is more important than how you say it.



      I thought it was by Eric Frank Russell, but can't find it in his work. It was probably written in the 1950's or early 1960's.










      share|improve this question
















      Russians and Americans are competing to make an alliance with an alien race that lives on a planet with a very thick atmosphere. Most of the plant life on the planet lives hanging in the air from gas bags. Because it is so easy to fly, the natives have developed very primitive aircraft. The Russians have sophisticated linguists who are trying to establish communication. The hero, an American, knows nothing about linguistics, but does know a thing or two about flying. He teaches the natives about the concept of a rudder, and they are so thankful they form an alliance with the Americans. The hero explains that having something to say is more important than how you say it.



      I thought it was by Eric Frank Russell, but can't find it in his work. It was probably written in the 1950's or early 1960's.







      story-identification






      share|improve this question















      share|improve this question













      share|improve this question




      share|improve this question








      edited Sep 3 '18 at 22:29









      Edlothiad

      54.6k21287298




      54.6k21287298










      asked Sep 3 '18 at 1:35









      Terry McConnellTerry McConnell

      391




      391






















          1 Answer
          1






          active

          oldest

          votes


















          6














          "Something to Say", a novelette by John Berryman, also the (unaccepted) answer to this other question; published in Analog Science Fiction & Science Fact, August 1966 and reprinted in the anthology Analog 6. Here is an Amazon customer review:




          Carina VI has been identified as having an intelligent population. The Federation intends to make contact following due careful procedure, but the competing blocs on Earth are seeking to get ahead of each other in this process.




          Russians and Americans are competing to make an alliance with an alien race




          One Bloc or the other is getting desperate," he said bitterly. He paused to light his smoke. "Somebody made an illegal landing during the last watch."

          "On Carina VI?" I asked, startled.

          "No. Here on Six Beta. Oh, it's plain enough what's on their mind. Whether it's the Dembloc or the Sovbloc I don't know, but one Bloc has decided the only way to get preference on Six is to land some contrabands on the planet before the Federation opens it up under the Treaty. With only a standard month left before we make our first landing, they have very little time. Obviously, they can't land a deep-space vehicle there without a grid, so they've got the hot idea of stealing one of our atmospheric probes."




          that lives on a planet with a very thick atmosphere.




          "This is one tremendously deep atmosphere. At the surface, pressures are about six times standard. But the oxygen percentage is only one sixth of standard. While that makes it breathable on the surface, way up here, at a quarter standard pressure, there isn't enough equivalent oxygen to keep a flea alive."




          Most of the plant life on the planet lives hanging in the air from gas bags.




          And above us, I suddenly realized, lay the forest. In the thick air, perhaps a couple thousand meters high, floated amorphous shapes, apparently equally made of large bladders, nearly transparent in the morning light, and fibrous strands holding them together. There was a good deal of greenery strung around the strands. They obviously had been the source of the rending thumps shortly before we crashed.

          "What are they?" Diane demanded, pointing up.

          "Flying trees, I guess," I said. "With this thick an atmosphere, a lot of things are possible. I'm guessing that by some inverted photosynthesis those plants separate hydrogen from water and secrete it in those great big bladders. As the sun comes up and they heat, I imagine they climb to some pretty respectable heights."




          Because it is so easy to fly, the natives have developed very primitive aircraft.




          There was a pilot in each of the soaring things, sitting, lying, or standing, I had no way of knowing, in an open cockpit. He was steering his glider with what appeared to be two hands, and his upper end—if that's what we were looking at—was shockingly human.

          Bird-like, or airplane-like, the stubby-winged gliders made a series of rough, slipping turns in a pattern and prepared to land single-file forty or fifty meters from where we sat in the bracken. As they flared out "over the fence" they wobbled in near-stalls, accentuated by the extremely low aspect ratio of their wings. At the comical last moment, the "landing gear" was extended. Just two of the most human-looking legs and feet you ever saw. Each pilot trotted a few steps and squatted down, grounding his glider.




          The Russians have sophisticated linguists who are trying to establish communication




          I laughed, backing away from her aggressive advance across the stone floor. A little common sense started percolating through my thick head. Our interests were adverse. She had landed on Six to grease the way for the Sovbloc, in violation of the Interplanetary Treaty. The mission I was part of on Six Beta had been recruited to prevent either Bloc from getting a preferred position.

          "You want to know too much," I said, continuing to chuckle. "It's time I clammed up."

          She shrugged, ramming her fists onto her hips, her feet apart. "You won't talk, eh? So I'll ask them." She sounded pretty smug.

          I let defeat sound in my voice. "You mean you can talk with them already?" I wanted to know.

          [. . . .]

          "The advantage of being a trained linguist," Diane told me. "And just to cheer you a little, L. C. Reamy, you might as well know that Sixian is a positional speech, like Chinese. But unlike Chinese, it is inflected about as much as Sanskrit."




          The hero, an American, knows nothing about linguistics, but does know a thing or two about flying. He teaches the natives about the concept of a rudder,




          On the opposite wall I drew with much more care. Here I laid out a better mousetrap. The improvement on their glider featured some very simple ideas. In the first place, I put some dihedral in the wings. Secondly, I increased the aspect ratio, so that span was about five times root chord, while sticking to their essentially correct idea of an elliptical plan-form. My biggest change, although only the engineering-minded would catch it, was in the empennage. I drew control horns on the rudder similar to those the natives had used to flex the stabilizer.




          and they are so thankful they form an alliance with the Americans. The hero explains that having something to say is more important than how you say it.




          The chief shook his head. "I can't understand it," he said to her. "Here you are, a prize linguist, able to talk a blue streak with the locals. And here's Reamy, making dumb-show with his hands. How does it occur that he has them in the palm of his hand, and you are still a captive?"

          She shook her head. "I should have killed him when I had the chance!" she said.

          "And you can't tell me how he did it?"

          "No, I can't," she said angrily.

          The chief turned back to me.

          "She overlooked one thing," I grinned at him. "You have to have something to say."







          share|improve this answer


























            Your Answer








            StackExchange.ready(function() {
            var channelOptions = {
            tags: "".split(" "),
            id: "186"
            };
            initTagRenderer("".split(" "), "".split(" "), channelOptions);

            StackExchange.using("externalEditor", function() {
            // Have to fire editor after snippets, if snippets enabled
            if (StackExchange.settings.snippets.snippetsEnabled) {
            StackExchange.using("snippets", function() {
            createEditor();
            });
            }
            else {
            createEditor();
            }
            });

            function createEditor() {
            StackExchange.prepareEditor({
            heartbeatType: 'answer',
            autoActivateHeartbeat: false,
            convertImagesToLinks: false,
            noModals: true,
            showLowRepImageUploadWarning: true,
            reputationToPostImages: null,
            bindNavPrevention: true,
            postfix: "",
            imageUploader: {
            brandingHtml: "Powered by u003ca class="icon-imgur-white" href="https://imgur.com/"u003eu003c/au003e",
            contentPolicyHtml: "User contributions licensed under u003ca href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/"u003ecc by-sa 3.0 with attribution requiredu003c/au003e u003ca href="https://stackoverflow.com/legal/content-policy"u003e(content policy)u003c/au003e",
            allowUrls: true
            },
            noCode: true, onDemand: true,
            discardSelector: ".discard-answer"
            ,immediatelyShowMarkdownHelp:true
            });


            }
            });














            draft saved

            draft discarded


















            StackExchange.ready(
            function () {
            StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fscifi.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f194116%2fstory-entitled-something-to-say%23new-answer', 'question_page');
            }
            );

            Post as a guest















            Required, but never shown

























            1 Answer
            1






            active

            oldest

            votes








            1 Answer
            1






            active

            oldest

            votes









            active

            oldest

            votes






            active

            oldest

            votes









            6














            "Something to Say", a novelette by John Berryman, also the (unaccepted) answer to this other question; published in Analog Science Fiction & Science Fact, August 1966 and reprinted in the anthology Analog 6. Here is an Amazon customer review:




            Carina VI has been identified as having an intelligent population. The Federation intends to make contact following due careful procedure, but the competing blocs on Earth are seeking to get ahead of each other in this process.




            Russians and Americans are competing to make an alliance with an alien race




            One Bloc or the other is getting desperate," he said bitterly. He paused to light his smoke. "Somebody made an illegal landing during the last watch."

            "On Carina VI?" I asked, startled.

            "No. Here on Six Beta. Oh, it's plain enough what's on their mind. Whether it's the Dembloc or the Sovbloc I don't know, but one Bloc has decided the only way to get preference on Six is to land some contrabands on the planet before the Federation opens it up under the Treaty. With only a standard month left before we make our first landing, they have very little time. Obviously, they can't land a deep-space vehicle there without a grid, so they've got the hot idea of stealing one of our atmospheric probes."




            that lives on a planet with a very thick atmosphere.




            "This is one tremendously deep atmosphere. At the surface, pressures are about six times standard. But the oxygen percentage is only one sixth of standard. While that makes it breathable on the surface, way up here, at a quarter standard pressure, there isn't enough equivalent oxygen to keep a flea alive."




            Most of the plant life on the planet lives hanging in the air from gas bags.




            And above us, I suddenly realized, lay the forest. In the thick air, perhaps a couple thousand meters high, floated amorphous shapes, apparently equally made of large bladders, nearly transparent in the morning light, and fibrous strands holding them together. There was a good deal of greenery strung around the strands. They obviously had been the source of the rending thumps shortly before we crashed.

            "What are they?" Diane demanded, pointing up.

            "Flying trees, I guess," I said. "With this thick an atmosphere, a lot of things are possible. I'm guessing that by some inverted photosynthesis those plants separate hydrogen from water and secrete it in those great big bladders. As the sun comes up and they heat, I imagine they climb to some pretty respectable heights."




            Because it is so easy to fly, the natives have developed very primitive aircraft.




            There was a pilot in each of the soaring things, sitting, lying, or standing, I had no way of knowing, in an open cockpit. He was steering his glider with what appeared to be two hands, and his upper end—if that's what we were looking at—was shockingly human.

            Bird-like, or airplane-like, the stubby-winged gliders made a series of rough, slipping turns in a pattern and prepared to land single-file forty or fifty meters from where we sat in the bracken. As they flared out "over the fence" they wobbled in near-stalls, accentuated by the extremely low aspect ratio of their wings. At the comical last moment, the "landing gear" was extended. Just two of the most human-looking legs and feet you ever saw. Each pilot trotted a few steps and squatted down, grounding his glider.




            The Russians have sophisticated linguists who are trying to establish communication




            I laughed, backing away from her aggressive advance across the stone floor. A little common sense started percolating through my thick head. Our interests were adverse. She had landed on Six to grease the way for the Sovbloc, in violation of the Interplanetary Treaty. The mission I was part of on Six Beta had been recruited to prevent either Bloc from getting a preferred position.

            "You want to know too much," I said, continuing to chuckle. "It's time I clammed up."

            She shrugged, ramming her fists onto her hips, her feet apart. "You won't talk, eh? So I'll ask them." She sounded pretty smug.

            I let defeat sound in my voice. "You mean you can talk with them already?" I wanted to know.

            [. . . .]

            "The advantage of being a trained linguist," Diane told me. "And just to cheer you a little, L. C. Reamy, you might as well know that Sixian is a positional speech, like Chinese. But unlike Chinese, it is inflected about as much as Sanskrit."




            The hero, an American, knows nothing about linguistics, but does know a thing or two about flying. He teaches the natives about the concept of a rudder,




            On the opposite wall I drew with much more care. Here I laid out a better mousetrap. The improvement on their glider featured some very simple ideas. In the first place, I put some dihedral in the wings. Secondly, I increased the aspect ratio, so that span was about five times root chord, while sticking to their essentially correct idea of an elliptical plan-form. My biggest change, although only the engineering-minded would catch it, was in the empennage. I drew control horns on the rudder similar to those the natives had used to flex the stabilizer.




            and they are so thankful they form an alliance with the Americans. The hero explains that having something to say is more important than how you say it.




            The chief shook his head. "I can't understand it," he said to her. "Here you are, a prize linguist, able to talk a blue streak with the locals. And here's Reamy, making dumb-show with his hands. How does it occur that he has them in the palm of his hand, and you are still a captive?"

            She shook her head. "I should have killed him when I had the chance!" she said.

            "And you can't tell me how he did it?"

            "No, I can't," she said angrily.

            The chief turned back to me.

            "She overlooked one thing," I grinned at him. "You have to have something to say."







            share|improve this answer






























              6














              "Something to Say", a novelette by John Berryman, also the (unaccepted) answer to this other question; published in Analog Science Fiction & Science Fact, August 1966 and reprinted in the anthology Analog 6. Here is an Amazon customer review:




              Carina VI has been identified as having an intelligent population. The Federation intends to make contact following due careful procedure, but the competing blocs on Earth are seeking to get ahead of each other in this process.




              Russians and Americans are competing to make an alliance with an alien race




              One Bloc or the other is getting desperate," he said bitterly. He paused to light his smoke. "Somebody made an illegal landing during the last watch."

              "On Carina VI?" I asked, startled.

              "No. Here on Six Beta. Oh, it's plain enough what's on their mind. Whether it's the Dembloc or the Sovbloc I don't know, but one Bloc has decided the only way to get preference on Six is to land some contrabands on the planet before the Federation opens it up under the Treaty. With only a standard month left before we make our first landing, they have very little time. Obviously, they can't land a deep-space vehicle there without a grid, so they've got the hot idea of stealing one of our atmospheric probes."




              that lives on a planet with a very thick atmosphere.




              "This is one tremendously deep atmosphere. At the surface, pressures are about six times standard. But the oxygen percentage is only one sixth of standard. While that makes it breathable on the surface, way up here, at a quarter standard pressure, there isn't enough equivalent oxygen to keep a flea alive."




              Most of the plant life on the planet lives hanging in the air from gas bags.




              And above us, I suddenly realized, lay the forest. In the thick air, perhaps a couple thousand meters high, floated amorphous shapes, apparently equally made of large bladders, nearly transparent in the morning light, and fibrous strands holding them together. There was a good deal of greenery strung around the strands. They obviously had been the source of the rending thumps shortly before we crashed.

              "What are they?" Diane demanded, pointing up.

              "Flying trees, I guess," I said. "With this thick an atmosphere, a lot of things are possible. I'm guessing that by some inverted photosynthesis those plants separate hydrogen from water and secrete it in those great big bladders. As the sun comes up and they heat, I imagine they climb to some pretty respectable heights."




              Because it is so easy to fly, the natives have developed very primitive aircraft.




              There was a pilot in each of the soaring things, sitting, lying, or standing, I had no way of knowing, in an open cockpit. He was steering his glider with what appeared to be two hands, and his upper end—if that's what we were looking at—was shockingly human.

              Bird-like, or airplane-like, the stubby-winged gliders made a series of rough, slipping turns in a pattern and prepared to land single-file forty or fifty meters from where we sat in the bracken. As they flared out "over the fence" they wobbled in near-stalls, accentuated by the extremely low aspect ratio of their wings. At the comical last moment, the "landing gear" was extended. Just two of the most human-looking legs and feet you ever saw. Each pilot trotted a few steps and squatted down, grounding his glider.




              The Russians have sophisticated linguists who are trying to establish communication




              I laughed, backing away from her aggressive advance across the stone floor. A little common sense started percolating through my thick head. Our interests were adverse. She had landed on Six to grease the way for the Sovbloc, in violation of the Interplanetary Treaty. The mission I was part of on Six Beta had been recruited to prevent either Bloc from getting a preferred position.

              "You want to know too much," I said, continuing to chuckle. "It's time I clammed up."

              She shrugged, ramming her fists onto her hips, her feet apart. "You won't talk, eh? So I'll ask them." She sounded pretty smug.

              I let defeat sound in my voice. "You mean you can talk with them already?" I wanted to know.

              [. . . .]

              "The advantage of being a trained linguist," Diane told me. "And just to cheer you a little, L. C. Reamy, you might as well know that Sixian is a positional speech, like Chinese. But unlike Chinese, it is inflected about as much as Sanskrit."




              The hero, an American, knows nothing about linguistics, but does know a thing or two about flying. He teaches the natives about the concept of a rudder,




              On the opposite wall I drew with much more care. Here I laid out a better mousetrap. The improvement on their glider featured some very simple ideas. In the first place, I put some dihedral in the wings. Secondly, I increased the aspect ratio, so that span was about five times root chord, while sticking to their essentially correct idea of an elliptical plan-form. My biggest change, although only the engineering-minded would catch it, was in the empennage. I drew control horns on the rudder similar to those the natives had used to flex the stabilizer.




              and they are so thankful they form an alliance with the Americans. The hero explains that having something to say is more important than how you say it.




              The chief shook his head. "I can't understand it," he said to her. "Here you are, a prize linguist, able to talk a blue streak with the locals. And here's Reamy, making dumb-show with his hands. How does it occur that he has them in the palm of his hand, and you are still a captive?"

              She shook her head. "I should have killed him when I had the chance!" she said.

              "And you can't tell me how he did it?"

              "No, I can't," she said angrily.

              The chief turned back to me.

              "She overlooked one thing," I grinned at him. "You have to have something to say."







              share|improve this answer




























                6












                6








                6







                "Something to Say", a novelette by John Berryman, also the (unaccepted) answer to this other question; published in Analog Science Fiction & Science Fact, August 1966 and reprinted in the anthology Analog 6. Here is an Amazon customer review:




                Carina VI has been identified as having an intelligent population. The Federation intends to make contact following due careful procedure, but the competing blocs on Earth are seeking to get ahead of each other in this process.




                Russians and Americans are competing to make an alliance with an alien race




                One Bloc or the other is getting desperate," he said bitterly. He paused to light his smoke. "Somebody made an illegal landing during the last watch."

                "On Carina VI?" I asked, startled.

                "No. Here on Six Beta. Oh, it's plain enough what's on their mind. Whether it's the Dembloc or the Sovbloc I don't know, but one Bloc has decided the only way to get preference on Six is to land some contrabands on the planet before the Federation opens it up under the Treaty. With only a standard month left before we make our first landing, they have very little time. Obviously, they can't land a deep-space vehicle there without a grid, so they've got the hot idea of stealing one of our atmospheric probes."




                that lives on a planet with a very thick atmosphere.




                "This is one tremendously deep atmosphere. At the surface, pressures are about six times standard. But the oxygen percentage is only one sixth of standard. While that makes it breathable on the surface, way up here, at a quarter standard pressure, there isn't enough equivalent oxygen to keep a flea alive."




                Most of the plant life on the planet lives hanging in the air from gas bags.




                And above us, I suddenly realized, lay the forest. In the thick air, perhaps a couple thousand meters high, floated amorphous shapes, apparently equally made of large bladders, nearly transparent in the morning light, and fibrous strands holding them together. There was a good deal of greenery strung around the strands. They obviously had been the source of the rending thumps shortly before we crashed.

                "What are they?" Diane demanded, pointing up.

                "Flying trees, I guess," I said. "With this thick an atmosphere, a lot of things are possible. I'm guessing that by some inverted photosynthesis those plants separate hydrogen from water and secrete it in those great big bladders. As the sun comes up and they heat, I imagine they climb to some pretty respectable heights."




                Because it is so easy to fly, the natives have developed very primitive aircraft.




                There was a pilot in each of the soaring things, sitting, lying, or standing, I had no way of knowing, in an open cockpit. He was steering his glider with what appeared to be two hands, and his upper end—if that's what we were looking at—was shockingly human.

                Bird-like, or airplane-like, the stubby-winged gliders made a series of rough, slipping turns in a pattern and prepared to land single-file forty or fifty meters from where we sat in the bracken. As they flared out "over the fence" they wobbled in near-stalls, accentuated by the extremely low aspect ratio of their wings. At the comical last moment, the "landing gear" was extended. Just two of the most human-looking legs and feet you ever saw. Each pilot trotted a few steps and squatted down, grounding his glider.




                The Russians have sophisticated linguists who are trying to establish communication




                I laughed, backing away from her aggressive advance across the stone floor. A little common sense started percolating through my thick head. Our interests were adverse. She had landed on Six to grease the way for the Sovbloc, in violation of the Interplanetary Treaty. The mission I was part of on Six Beta had been recruited to prevent either Bloc from getting a preferred position.

                "You want to know too much," I said, continuing to chuckle. "It's time I clammed up."

                She shrugged, ramming her fists onto her hips, her feet apart. "You won't talk, eh? So I'll ask them." She sounded pretty smug.

                I let defeat sound in my voice. "You mean you can talk with them already?" I wanted to know.

                [. . . .]

                "The advantage of being a trained linguist," Diane told me. "And just to cheer you a little, L. C. Reamy, you might as well know that Sixian is a positional speech, like Chinese. But unlike Chinese, it is inflected about as much as Sanskrit."




                The hero, an American, knows nothing about linguistics, but does know a thing or two about flying. He teaches the natives about the concept of a rudder,




                On the opposite wall I drew with much more care. Here I laid out a better mousetrap. The improvement on their glider featured some very simple ideas. In the first place, I put some dihedral in the wings. Secondly, I increased the aspect ratio, so that span was about five times root chord, while sticking to their essentially correct idea of an elliptical plan-form. My biggest change, although only the engineering-minded would catch it, was in the empennage. I drew control horns on the rudder similar to those the natives had used to flex the stabilizer.




                and they are so thankful they form an alliance with the Americans. The hero explains that having something to say is more important than how you say it.




                The chief shook his head. "I can't understand it," he said to her. "Here you are, a prize linguist, able to talk a blue streak with the locals. And here's Reamy, making dumb-show with his hands. How does it occur that he has them in the palm of his hand, and you are still a captive?"

                She shook her head. "I should have killed him when I had the chance!" she said.

                "And you can't tell me how he did it?"

                "No, I can't," she said angrily.

                The chief turned back to me.

                "She overlooked one thing," I grinned at him. "You have to have something to say."







                share|improve this answer















                "Something to Say", a novelette by John Berryman, also the (unaccepted) answer to this other question; published in Analog Science Fiction & Science Fact, August 1966 and reprinted in the anthology Analog 6. Here is an Amazon customer review:




                Carina VI has been identified as having an intelligent population. The Federation intends to make contact following due careful procedure, but the competing blocs on Earth are seeking to get ahead of each other in this process.




                Russians and Americans are competing to make an alliance with an alien race




                One Bloc or the other is getting desperate," he said bitterly. He paused to light his smoke. "Somebody made an illegal landing during the last watch."

                "On Carina VI?" I asked, startled.

                "No. Here on Six Beta. Oh, it's plain enough what's on their mind. Whether it's the Dembloc or the Sovbloc I don't know, but one Bloc has decided the only way to get preference on Six is to land some contrabands on the planet before the Federation opens it up under the Treaty. With only a standard month left before we make our first landing, they have very little time. Obviously, they can't land a deep-space vehicle there without a grid, so they've got the hot idea of stealing one of our atmospheric probes."




                that lives on a planet with a very thick atmosphere.




                "This is one tremendously deep atmosphere. At the surface, pressures are about six times standard. But the oxygen percentage is only one sixth of standard. While that makes it breathable on the surface, way up here, at a quarter standard pressure, there isn't enough equivalent oxygen to keep a flea alive."




                Most of the plant life on the planet lives hanging in the air from gas bags.




                And above us, I suddenly realized, lay the forest. In the thick air, perhaps a couple thousand meters high, floated amorphous shapes, apparently equally made of large bladders, nearly transparent in the morning light, and fibrous strands holding them together. There was a good deal of greenery strung around the strands. They obviously had been the source of the rending thumps shortly before we crashed.

                "What are they?" Diane demanded, pointing up.

                "Flying trees, I guess," I said. "With this thick an atmosphere, a lot of things are possible. I'm guessing that by some inverted photosynthesis those plants separate hydrogen from water and secrete it in those great big bladders. As the sun comes up and they heat, I imagine they climb to some pretty respectable heights."




                Because it is so easy to fly, the natives have developed very primitive aircraft.




                There was a pilot in each of the soaring things, sitting, lying, or standing, I had no way of knowing, in an open cockpit. He was steering his glider with what appeared to be two hands, and his upper end—if that's what we were looking at—was shockingly human.

                Bird-like, or airplane-like, the stubby-winged gliders made a series of rough, slipping turns in a pattern and prepared to land single-file forty or fifty meters from where we sat in the bracken. As they flared out "over the fence" they wobbled in near-stalls, accentuated by the extremely low aspect ratio of their wings. At the comical last moment, the "landing gear" was extended. Just two of the most human-looking legs and feet you ever saw. Each pilot trotted a few steps and squatted down, grounding his glider.




                The Russians have sophisticated linguists who are trying to establish communication




                I laughed, backing away from her aggressive advance across the stone floor. A little common sense started percolating through my thick head. Our interests were adverse. She had landed on Six to grease the way for the Sovbloc, in violation of the Interplanetary Treaty. The mission I was part of on Six Beta had been recruited to prevent either Bloc from getting a preferred position.

                "You want to know too much," I said, continuing to chuckle. "It's time I clammed up."

                She shrugged, ramming her fists onto her hips, her feet apart. "You won't talk, eh? So I'll ask them." She sounded pretty smug.

                I let defeat sound in my voice. "You mean you can talk with them already?" I wanted to know.

                [. . . .]

                "The advantage of being a trained linguist," Diane told me. "And just to cheer you a little, L. C. Reamy, you might as well know that Sixian is a positional speech, like Chinese. But unlike Chinese, it is inflected about as much as Sanskrit."




                The hero, an American, knows nothing about linguistics, but does know a thing or two about flying. He teaches the natives about the concept of a rudder,




                On the opposite wall I drew with much more care. Here I laid out a better mousetrap. The improvement on their glider featured some very simple ideas. In the first place, I put some dihedral in the wings. Secondly, I increased the aspect ratio, so that span was about five times root chord, while sticking to their essentially correct idea of an elliptical plan-form. My biggest change, although only the engineering-minded would catch it, was in the empennage. I drew control horns on the rudder similar to those the natives had used to flex the stabilizer.




                and they are so thankful they form an alliance with the Americans. The hero explains that having something to say is more important than how you say it.




                The chief shook his head. "I can't understand it," he said to her. "Here you are, a prize linguist, able to talk a blue streak with the locals. And here's Reamy, making dumb-show with his hands. How does it occur that he has them in the palm of his hand, and you are still a captive?"

                She shook her head. "I should have killed him when I had the chance!" she said.

                "And you can't tell me how he did it?"

                "No, I can't," she said angrily.

                The chief turned back to me.

                "She overlooked one thing," I grinned at him. "You have to have something to say."








                share|improve this answer














                share|improve this answer



                share|improve this answer








                edited 1 min ago

























                answered Sep 3 '18 at 4:49









                user14111user14111

                104k6406522




                104k6406522






























                    draft saved

                    draft discarded




















































                    Thanks for contributing an answer to Science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange!


                    • Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!

                    But avoid



                    • Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.

                    • Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.


                    To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.




                    draft saved


                    draft discarded














                    StackExchange.ready(
                    function () {
                    StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fscifi.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f194116%2fstory-entitled-something-to-say%23new-answer', 'question_page');
                    }
                    );

                    Post as a guest















                    Required, but never shown





















































                    Required, but never shown














                    Required, but never shown












                    Required, but never shown







                    Required, but never shown

































                    Required, but never shown














                    Required, but never shown












                    Required, but never shown







                    Required, but never shown







                    Popular posts from this blog

                    Gersau Kjelder | Navigasjonsmeny46°59′0″N 8°31′0″E46°59′0″N...

                    Hestehale Innhaldsliste Hestehale på kvinner | Hestehale på menn | Galleri | Sjå òg |...

                    What is the “three and three hundred thousand syndrome”?Who wrote the book Arena?What five creatures were...